🇵🇰 Pakistan · 🇹🇷 Türkiye
*By Priya Mehta, The Global Office
A World Bank survey of 332 Turkish firms found managers rating their own companies an average 7.8 out of 10 for management quality — the largest gap between self-perception and measured reality of any country in the entire study. Pakistan has no equivalent self-rating data, mostly because, per Dawn's own longtime industry columnists, a large share of its firms don't have enough of a middle-management layer left to survey in the first place.
The same World Bank report puts a number on who's actually running Turkish companies: family- and founder-owned or -managed firms make up 72% of the national sample, with operations and people management as relative strengths and monitoring and performance-target-setting as the weakest measured areas. That's a genuinely specific profile — a management culture that is good at running the floor day-to-day and comparatively weak at the structured feedback loops that would let employees know, with any precision, how they're actually doing.
| ✅ Do | ❌ Don't |
|---|---|
| Show deference to seniority, age, and position — decisions flow top-down, and that's the system working, not a flaw to route around | Expect a merit-only promotion ladder by default outside multinationals — family and ownership ties often matter more |
| Invest real time building a personal relationship before expecting business results | Push for business substance before any relationship exists |
| Use titles with surname, and respectful forms like "Sahib" or "Begum" | Offer a handshake to a Pakistani woman unless she extends her hand first |
| Accept offered tea or refreshments graciously | Offer pork or alcohol at a business meal — both are religiously prohibited |
| Listen for indirect refusals — "that may be difficult" or "Inshallah" often function as a soft no | Raise India-Pakistan relations, military politics, or sectarian topics in conversation |
| Escalate directly when needed — many firms genuinely lack a middle layer, so don't waste time hunting for an intermediate manager who may not exist | Eat, drink, or smoke in front of fasting colleagues during Ramadan daylight hours |
| ✅ Do | ❌ Don't |
|---|---|
| Book meetings one to two weeks ahead and send attendees' titles and roles in advance | Use a first name alone, or the informal "sen," with someone you haven't been invited to address that way |
| Greet the most senior person first, then greet everyone else individually | Push to discuss business substance in the very first meeting — relationship-building comes first |
| Expect the most senior family member or executive to make the final call | Bring a lawyer to the table early — it can read as a signal of distrust |
| Accept tea or Turkish coffee even if you only take a few sips | Schedule meetings during Ramadan or in the common July–August vacation period |
| Dress and arrive formally, especially for a senior visitor | Arrive casually for a senior visitor — a documented real case shows this can tangibly damage the relationship |
| Recognize rigid hierarchical communication as a genuine, acknowledged retention risk, not just "how it's done" | Mistake younger employees' formal deference for actual satisfaction with the status quo |
Pakistan's management culture, per Dawn's own named industry commentary, runs largely on what local writers call "seth culture" — an owner-worker model in which top executives handle ground-level issues directly because many companies simply have no real middle-management layer, boards are frequently stacked with family and friends, and promotions track social standing as often as output. Gallup's most recent figures put employee engagement at just 4% — among the lowest recorded anywhere — with 28% actively disengaged, and daily anger (34%) and sadness (40%) both running well above global averages even though reported stress sits slightly below the global figure, a striking emotional profile for a single labour market. Hofstede records an Indulgence score of 0 for Pakistan — among the most restrained scores the organization has ever measured for any country — alongside a Power Distance of 55, numbers that together describe a workplace built on sustained deference rather than negotiated authority. Turkish Minute's own analysis of the Gallup data adds a sharper edge to the Turkish numbers specifically: 52% of Turkish workers report they are actively seeking new employment, and Turkish engagement has fallen from a 2016 peak of 17% to just 8% today — a near-halving over roughly a decade, during a period when the country's own management-research apparatus was simultaneously getting better at measuring the problem.
Türkiye's hierarchy looks, on paper, better documented and more self-aware. The World Bank's management-quality survey found Turkish firms averaging 2.71 against a global mean of 2.83, with 55–70% falling below the bottom quartile of comparable US firms — and, notably, found that more hierarchical Turkish firms scored very slightly better on measured management quality, a small but real wrinkle against the easy assumption that hierarchy and good management are opposites. Great Place to Work Türkiye's own 2024 survey of 600 companies and 170,000 workers, reported by Hürriyet Daily News, found a real leadership-employee perception gap: 83% of senior leaders rated their workplace as exceptional, versus only 66% of employees who agreed. CEO Eyüp Toprak's own diagnosis, delivered on the record, was blunt: rigid, hierarchical communication, he said, "pushes younger workers away." Hofstede's Power Distance figure for Türkiye sits at 66, with Uncertainty Avoidance at a striking 85 — a culture that plans meticulously and defers formally, but one whose own institutional voices are now openly naming the hierarchy as a retention problem rather than defending it as tradition. That same World Bank data contains one more nuance worth keeping: firms with more hierarchical structures actually scored marginally better on measured management quality, a weak but statistically real effect — hierarchy, on this particular measure, correlates with slightly better-run operations, not automatically worse ones, which complicates any simple "flatten everything" prescription a newly arrived manager might be tempted to import.
The Morning Brief
Enjoying this? Get it in your inbox.
The real divergence is self-awareness, not hierarchy itself — both countries score similarly high on deference and formal structure, but Türkiye's own corporate research apparatus (Great Place to Work, the World Bank) is actively measuring and publicly naming the gap between how leadership sees itself and how staff experience it, while Pakistan's commentary, per Dawn's columnists, treats the absence of real middle management as a structural fact of life rather than a solvable metric. One country has a hierarchy it's beginning to interrogate. The other has a hierarchy it has mostly just adapted around.
Reddit r/developersPak (via mirror) — A software engineering intern at a small Pakistani services agency described a team lead with roughly three years' experience who pushed a secrets file into the shared repository, asked for a Docker image with those secrets baked in, and stated technically incorrect claims as unchallengeable fact; the most common advice from peers was to quietly build a portfolio and aim for a foreign-owned employer rather than push back internally.
Pakistaniat.com comment thread — A commenter writing as "Irum Sarfaraz" criticized the national habit of late nights and late mornings as poor time management rather than genuine productivity, while the site's own managing editor, Owais Mughal, argued that routinely long hours signal poor project planning rather than diligence — a direct, named pushback against "long hours equal a good employee" as a cultural default.
Glassdoor, Getir (Turkish-founded company) — An employee called the HR function "the worst I've ever seen," describing leadership decisions made with zero employee input and engineering managers and team leads described as having no real power to question or change a CEO's decision.
Hürriyet Daily News / HR-Polska cross-cultural consulting case study — A documented real account: an American country manager picked up a visiting Turkish executive from the airport in a polo shirt and jeans despite strong business results, and the visit was formally scored a failure for "lack of respect for supervisor"; on the next visit, the same manager arranged a suit and a chauffeured car, and the visit was judged a success.
Great Place to Work Türkiye data, via Hürriyet Daily News — CEO Eyüp Toprak stated on the record that rigid, hierarchical communication "pushes younger workers away," and that building trust has to be a strategic leadership commitment rather than a short-term motivational exercise — a named industry insider's direct diagnosis of his own country's management culture.
If you're taking a management role in either market, the honest advice is the same but the risk profile differs: in Pakistan, build your authority through relationship and patience, because the formal structure you're used to relying on elsewhere may simply not exist beneath you. In Türkiye, build it through formality and timing, but don't assume the hierarchy is settled or beloved — the country's own leading workplace researchers are telling you, on the record, that it's already starting to cost them their youngest talent. Respect the chain of command in both places. Just don't assume either chain is as stable as it looks from the top rung.
If you're arriving as a junior hire rather than a manager, the calculus is simpler but the stakes are real: in Pakistan, invest in the relationship with whoever actually holds decision-making power, formal title notwithstanding, because that's where the real organization lives. In Türkiye, invest in patience during the relationship-building phase before pushing for substance, and take the country's own Great Place to Work data as a signal — the hierarchy you're adapting to is already being named as a problem by the people who run it, which is a better position to negotiate from than you might think. Either way, resist the urge to flatten a hierarchy you don't yet fully understand — learn how it actually functions first, then decide, deliberately, which parts are worth quietly pushing against. Both countries' own data suggests the hierarchy is already under more internal scrutiny than its reputation lets on — your job is to read the room accurately, not to arrive with the reform already drafted in your carry-on luggage, however well-intentioned the draft might be.
Subscriber Only
Subscribe to The Alignment Times and get every article delivered to your inbox.
Photo by Tima Miroshnichenko via Pexels
Priya Mehta
Staff writer covering financial markets and corporate strategy. Has strong opinions about spreadsheets.