🇮🇳 🇦🇺 By Suki Nakamura, Out of Office
Personal space is not a universal human right, it is a cultural setting, and nowhere is this clearer than the jump cut from an Indian railway platform to an Australian bus stop. In India, the queue is a dense, breathing organism that closes around you the second you pause, strangers' shoulders finding yours with a casualness that would get you arrested in Melbourne. In Australia, four people can form a queue with enough spacing between them to land a small aircraft, and the person who stands too close will receive a look so devastatingly polite you'll apologise without knowing what for.
I have been queue-hugged by a Mumbai commuter who I'm fairly sure was using me as a wind-break. I have also stood a perfectly respectable arm's length from a Sydney bus queue and still been eyed with the mild suspicion usually reserved for someone who's just admitted to liking Vegemite the wrong way.
Photo by Shantum Singh via Pexels
| ✅ Do | ❌ Don't |
|---|---|
| Accept physical proximity as the default, not an aggression — queues, trains, and markets run on a closeness that has nothing to do with personal boundaries as the West defines them | Take it personally when someone brushes past, stands close, or cuts into what you thought was an orderly line — the social contract around queuing is genuinely different here |
| Expect noise as ambient, not hostile — honking, loud phone calls, and overlapping conversations are the soundtrack of public space, not a breach of etiquette | Assume everyone agrees this is fine; plenty of urban, younger Indians are publicly, vocally frustrated with exactly this, per ongoing local op-ed debates about "civic sense" |
| Use the "line versus mob" skill — identify the actual front of a queue by watching hands and bodies, not by assuming a tidy single file exists | Be shocked by phone calls on speakerphone in public — it's extremely common and not considered remotely rude in most of the country |
| Lean into negotiation and gentle assertiveness in crowded spaces — a firm, friendly "excuse me" repeated calmly works better than passive waiting | Wait patiently for a gap that will "naturally" open in a crowd — it generally won't, and assertive but polite insertion is the actual local skill |
| ✅ Do | ❌ Don't |
|---|---|
| Queue in a strict, almost sacred single file, with generous personal space — jumping a queue here is treated as a minor moral failing, not a logistics shortcut | Stand closer than arm's length to a stranger in any queue context; Australians maintain a buffer zone that reads as mandatory, not optional |
| Keep your voice down in public transport, waiting rooms, and shared spaces — loud phone conversations draw real, if silent, social disapproval | Cut in line "just this once" even for something minor; it's one of the more reliable ways to get a quietly furious reaction from otherwise easygoing locals |
| Say "sorry" reflexively, even when someone else bumps into you — it's a national verbal tic that smooths almost every public interaction | Mistake Australian informality for lax social rules; the casual tone masks a surprisingly firm, unspoken etiquette code around space and turn-taking |
| Notice and respect the unspoken "personal bubble" on public transport — an empty seat next to someone is often left empty deliberately as a courtesy | Assume rural or remote Australia follows identical norms to Sydney or Melbourne; etiquette tightens and loosens noticeably by region |
What reads to a newly arrived foreigner as "no queue culture" in India is, on closer and more generous inspection, a different queue culture entirely — one built on density, assertiveness, and constant micro-negotiation rather than the rigid single-file model most Western and East Asian cities default to. Scroll.in's own domestic cultural commentary has interrogated this at length, with local writers asking, pointedly, why so many Indians seem comfortable on speakerphone in a quiet carriage, or unwilling to hold a line — and the honest answer offered by most of that commentary isn't "nobody cares," it's that public space here has historically been treated as genuinely shared and elastic, something you claim actively rather than wait passively to be granted.
This plays out at every scale. A railway platform queue isn't really a line, it's a crowd with directional intent, and successfully boarding a Mumbai local train requires reading body language and claiming space with a confidence that feels aggressive to newcomers and entirely normal to everyone else. Noise follows the same logic — a market, a train carriage, a wedding, all operate at a volume that would be socially sanctioned as "too loud" almost anywhere in the Anglophone West, because communal space here has never been coded as a place for silence.
What's genuinely interesting, and often missed by outsiders eager to essentialise this as simply "Indian culture," is how contested it is internally — op-eds about "civic sense," viral Reddit threads from Indians themselves asking why queuing is so chaotic, and a visible, often youth-led frustration with exactly the behaviours foreigners notice. This isn't a monolith; it's a live cultural argument, and you're watching it happen in real time every time you're in a queue.
Deccan Chronicle's own columnists have gone further still, framing the entire subject as a genuine ongoing national debate about whether India's public-space norms need active reform or whether outsiders simply fail to read a system that, chaotic as it looks, actually functions through its own internal logic of eye contact, body positioning, and mutual, unspoken give-and-take. The honest expat position sits somewhere between the two: the system works, demonstrably, millions of people navigate it daily without incident, but it works through skills — reading intent, claiming space assertively but without actual aggression — that nobody explicitly teaches you and that take genuine months to internalise.
The Morning Brief
Enjoying this? Get it in your inbox.
Australia runs almost the exact inverse operating system. Etiquette guides — Federation University's own newcomer orientation materials chief among them — consistently flag queuing discipline as one of the most rigid unwritten rules in the country: single file, generous spacing, and an almost moral weight attached to jumping ahead. The famous Australian informality — thongs in the office car park, first names for everyone including your boss — coexists with a surprisingly firm, unspoken code around turn-taking and personal space that catches plenty of newcomers off guard precisely because the culture otherwise feels so relaxed.
The noise norms track the same pattern. Loud public phone calls, especially on trains and buses, draw real disapproval — rarely spoken aloud, because confrontation itself is also faintly taboo, but communicated through pointed silence, a look, a slightly exaggerated sigh. "Sorry" functions as the national social lubricant, deployed reflexively even when someone else is clearly at fault, smoothing over the exact friction points that, in India, would simply be absorbed as ambient normal.
What expat accounts repeatedly flag as the genuine adjustment isn't the rules themselves, which are easy enough to learn, but their invisibility — nobody will tell you directly that you've breached etiquette, you'll simply feel the room's temperature drop a few degrees and have to reverse-engineer what you did wrong.
Federation University's own newcomer materials specifically single out personal space on public transport as a frequent flashpoint: Australians will often leave an empty seat beside a stranger deliberately, as a courtesy, and will read someone deliberately choosing to sit directly adjacent when other seats are free as mildly, unnervingly forward. It's the exact inverse of the Mumbai local train, where declining to use available adjacent space would itself look strange. Expats moving between the two countries describe a genuine physical recalibration period — weeks of either feeling rudely crowded or, just as often, feeling bizarrely, suspiciously alone in a room full of people.
India wins if you want public space that feels alive, loud, and unpretentiously communal — you will never feel alone in a crowd, for better and worse. Australia wins if you want predictability and a four-metre buffer zone you can actually count on. Neither is objectively ruder; they're optimised for opposite things — India for density management, Australia for individual space preservation — and the expat who thrives in one will spend their first six months in the other either suffocated or lonely, usually both, in sequence.
It helps to remember these norms emerged from genuinely different population math. India's public-space culture evolved to let enormous numbers of people share finite space without it collapsing into constant conflict; the elbow-forward assertiveness that reads as rude to outsiders is, structurally, what keeps a Mumbai platform functional at rush hour. Australia's spacious courtesy evolved in a country with a tiny population scattered across a continent, where personal space was never scarce and so became, almost by default, a thing to protect rather than negotiate. You're not really adjusting to rudeness or politeness in either direction. You're adjusting to arithmetic.
Photo by zhang kaiyv via Pexels
"I got genuinely annoyed at people cutting the queue for my first year here, then realised the 'queue' I was imagining never actually existed as a concept — you have to just go for it." — r/AskIndia, paraphrased
"Someone stood one arm's length from me at a Woolworths checkout and I felt it in my whole body. Four months in Sydney and I've fully absorbed the bubble." — ExpatExchange Melbourne culture-shock thread, paraphrased
"Nobody will ever tell an Australian to their face they're being rude. You just slowly realise the whole bus has gone quiet because your call was too loud." — r/AskAnAustralian, paraphrased
India will teach you to claim space with your elbows and your voice; Australia will teach you to apologise for existing within four metres of a stranger. Pack accordingly — and for heaven's sake, if you're moving from one to the other, warn your new neighbours before your first phone call on speaker.
Subscriber Only
Subscribe to The Alignment Times and get every article delivered to your inbox.
Photo by Nur Bhuiyan via Pexels
Suki Nakamura
Staff writer covering financial markets and corporate strategy. Has strong opinions about spreadsheets.