A thought experiment in valuations, expectations, and why we keep pretending private companies are public
Here's what we know: SpaceX remains privately held. There is no IPO. There are no public shares, no trading prices, no lock-up expirations. And yet.
Yet every time Elon posts about raising capital, every analyst estimates a valuation, every venture firm whispers about secondary markets, we collectively perform a ritual. We price SpaceX as if Wall Street could actually own a piece. We calculate what it would be worth if you could buy it on Friday afternoon. We debate the gap between hype and fundamentals for a company whose fundamentals we're essentially inventing.
It's instructive, this game we play. The numbers tell us something true even if the premise is false: SpaceX's valuation—whatever it actually is—has always been priced for perfection. For flawless execution in a business where execution is genuinely hard. For the multiplanetary dream to be worth more than the rocket that occasionally fails to launch.
The Morning Brief
Enjoying this? Get it in your inbox.
The real story isn't that SpaceX went public and disappointed. It's that we've already decided what its public market price would be, and we've already started arguing about whether it's worth it. We've done the valuation without the company having to do anything as inconvenient as actual disclosure.
So when Starship has a rough test day, or when acquisition rumors surface, or when the burn rate becomes visible in leaks and court filings—we adjust our fictional stock price accordingly. Up. Down. Repeat.
The gravity metaphor writes itself. Sometimes the hardest thing to escape isn't physics. It's the shared delusion that private companies behave like public ones.
Subscriber Only
Subscribe to The Alignment Times and get every article delivered to your inbox.
Photo by Amar Preciado via Pexels
Danny Fisk
Staff writer covering financial markets and corporate strategy. Has strong opinions about spreadsheets.
Study Confirms What Every Introvert Has Known Since 2009
Apr 4, 2026
Man Explains Resilience Using Story About His Uber Driver
Apr 3, 2026